HomeIndia tour of EnglandAre we overanalysing India's loss at Edgbaston?

Are we overanalysing India’s loss at Edgbaston?

- Advertisement -

India tour of England 2018

India lost the opening Test at Edgbaston. The result is out there for us all. India lost by 31 runs.
England played well as a unit. India didn’t. India faltered at the end of the day. England didn’t.
A slim target of 194 went unscaled. It’s as simple as that. The ramifications were perhaps simpler.

Kohli, the only scorer.

Virat Kohli
Virat Kohli was the lone warrior for India

None other than Kohli could score. Murali  Vijay faltered. So did Rahul, Vijay and Dhawan. Rahane produced a shocker in both innings.
While England’s heads were raised in pride, India’s weren’t. You can recount the outcome even whilst sleep-walking.
And there we have it.
Regardless of what you do now, the outcome cannot be changed. Are we not registering that?
Even if the ‘God of Cricket’ got involved right now, nothing could be changed.
This poses a frank question.

- Advertisement -

Does cribbing about Edgbaston make sense?

India need to step-up (Image; Hindustan Times)

Agreed, India didn’t bring their A-game from the very top drawer.
Surely, in a team-based sport, it doesn’t help if you rely on individual performances.
Then even if that means, Ashwin ruining England’s batting or Kohli producing over 200 runs in a single Test, it doesn’t do the job.
Here’s what
can’t be ignored
One that should not escape the keen eye of the Indian observer.
In the past 72 hours or so, there may not be a single sporting publication around the world that hasn’t missed an opportunity to have a go at India.
Fair point.
Why shouldn’t India be criticised? The job of a publication is to analyse. They also give the devil its due where its worth it. They are also tasked with thinning the floor beneath one’s feet where its necessary.
But no expert theory now can change the outcome of the contest. Can it?
Whether a Gavaskar, Harsha, the common fan glued to the television at a workplace or the gangly youth in college canteen who has his own fair share of heavy-handed criticism to give- all have keenly indulged.

Constructive criticism makes sense.

Sunil Gavaskar was of the view that Indians should have had intense practice sessions instead of rest (Image: sports.ndtv.com)

But are we hearing anything of that kind? But Sir Sunny must be credited for directing some sense.
He was of the view a lack of practice and lack of onerous preparation before a Test leads to such outcomes
In here lies a question.
How much practice does India really need for acclimatizing to English conditions?
Haven’t they already played a T20 and ODI series? Runs were scored, sixes were struck, India’s batsmen stepped out, made use of the crease, took some diving catches, got a chance to play Rashid, see the form of Buttler and Bairstow- what was missing?
You cannot help if an Anderson or Broad aren’t played in ODIs, can you? Unfortunately, the Indian team isn’t that powerful as yet as to be making selections on England’s behalf.
So, does playing multiple contests on bouncy, turning tracks not warrant enough practice? It would be silly to ignore that Indians didn’t hit the nets prior to the start of the Edgbaston Test.

Then comes a bouncer by Mike Brearley

A successful captain in his own right, Brearley singled out Virat Kohli’s epic amid the staggering loss at Edgbaston.
He wasn’t wrong. But where his opinion translates to hitting below the belt is when he says Kohli’s aggression could be counterproductive to his team.
That’s a first.
It must be debated how can a player’s aggression be counter-productive for his own team?
A year ago, when asked about whether Virat’s aggressive instincts as a player and batsman do his game any good, Dravid replied in characteristic simplicity, “all players have a different mechanism to cope with pressure, mine was about being calm, Virat is spurred by a fierce contest. So if it works for him, where’s the harm in that?”
Now no matter what you do, whether you send Virat to a Buddhist Monk or to a Vipassana meditation camp, he cannot eschew his aggressive style. Why should he? He would’ve copped up criticism had he failed to produce runs and only rested with mimicking the bat-drop upon Root’s dismissal.
But he was India’s star batsman.

So how on earth is Virat’s natural style countering his team’s?

Kohli was dropped by David Malan (Image: sport360)

Take Virat’s exceptional knock out of the Edgbaston hammering, where do you see India then?
Perhaps, what doesn’t occur to those who are constantly tweeting and Facebooking about the Edgbaston loss is that how different might have the contest been had Kohli’s catch been taken by Malan?
England have responded by axing Malan.
But that’s in the aftermath.  They didn’t make opinion pieces out of it.
What deserves a greater discussion is how India might react at the start of the Second Test. Where’s the sense in going on and on about Dhawan’s failure?
There you have it. His results are in front of you. Make a change if necessary, but what are you precisely earning by taking a dig repeatedly.
Australia didn’t spare Waugh brothers the axe in the late nineties when their form dipped. But their media didn’t go into an overdrive. Fans moved on, critics remained silent and Australia continued playing.

Does that mean in the absence of social media, things were quieter?

Sam Curran silenced Inda with his strong all-round performance

Probably? Probably, not?
And does that mean, with the presence of social media, cricketing outcomes can be changed? No way.
It’s still those 11 men out there who hold key.
In an age no stranger to trolls and a meme-overload, it’s hardly a surprise that armchair activism and blogging from the four walls is the precedent.
But precedents don’t define actions, do they?
Why engage in diatribe or shenanigans where all we can do is to hope for a better outcome ahead?
The series is still alive, 4 Tests remain. Let’s hope for a more closer contest.
Skip over-analysing for a change

- Advertisement -
Dev Tyagi
Dev Tyagi
Dravid believer, admirer of - the square drive, Drew Barrymore, Germany, Finland, Electric Mobility, simplicity and the power of the written word! Absolutely admire contributing to KyroSports

15 Highly Educated Cricketers Of All Time

Cricket is a game of passion and dedication. A sport in which one involves themselves in camps and practice since early childhood. Due to...

Do we often under-appreciate Andy Flower? What’s his legacy?

There's a hint of sadness in noting that Zimbabwe has never been a dominant power in world cricket. But nothing could be sadder than...

Why are more and more MotoGP riders using the Noson nasal dilator?

Introduction MotoGP riders or athletes are physically fit and healthy individuals and their muscles are continuously functioning and used during the performance. As a fan...

How Come UFC Fighters Have Cauliflower Ears But Boxers Don’t?

The UFC has come a long way since its early days, wherein the fights seemed like modern-day gladiators due to its brutality and inconsistent...

5 spinners who can be India’s potential finger-spinners

The Indian cricket team has always been proud of its ability to produce world-class batsmen and similarly potent spinners. Though in recent times, the...

IPL 2018: The beautiful Sawai Mansingh Stadium, Jaipur

Being seated in the Sawai Mansingh stadium brings a different world, a world of difference away from the palpable excitement of watching truly India’s...

Top 5 Left Wingers In The World, Based On 2019-20 Season

Owing to the fact that football has evolved a lot since its inception and the tactics have changed a lot, the role of wingers...

The astonishing decline of Mario Balotelli

There was a time when Mario Balotelli was on top of the world.  The Italian talisman had scored two goals in the Euro 2012 semi-finals,...

What can be expected from the 2018 Azerbaijan Grand Prix?

Heat in the air and heat inside the car- that's been the story of the Azerbaijan Grand prix. As F1 parks itself at Baku...

How Suresh Raina Batted India Into The Finals of 2011 World Cup

Its been 9 years, since India won the Cricket World Cup defeating Sri Lanka on 2 April, 2011. The images and visuals of...

IPL 2018: The best from the West Indies

When one of nature's treacherous attacks on mankind- earthquakes- strike, their impact is measured on Richter's scale. When West Indians strike in a tournament...

Big change for India Women’s cricket as BCCI looks to finalise bowling coach soon

We are not even at the halfway stage of the 2018 cricketing season. It clearly seems there's no stopping India's women's cricket team. The...

Age Fraud in Indian Cricket: Are players really to be blamed?

There have been times while watching a cricket match when we tend to hear commentators comment on cricketers’ age. We as fans have many...

Ajax XI if they didn’t sell their star players

Based in Amsterdam, AFC Ajax, who incidentally draw their name from the legendary Greek hero of the same name, are the most successful club...

5 famous players to play for both Leeds United and Liverpool

Leeds United are back in the Premier League after 16 years and will play Liverpool at Anfield on Saturday in their very first match...

- Advertisement -

- Advertisement -